West Devon Homes - Who Should Take the Credit?

It's simply not true for a single party group to claim credit for establishing West Devon Homes (WDH). It was a decision not just of the whole council, but of the council's tenants as well. The Housing Committee's chairman for almost the whole time I have been a councillor has been an independent councillor who made it his particular speciality. During the 1995-99 council, the Lib Dem group had half of the seats and tried to "control" the council. It put its own members into all the committee chairmanships. That was a very mixed success.

In the case of the Housing Committee, it was such a failure that the long-serving independent ex-chairman was put back in the chair. Even the Lib Dem group at the time had to agree to that.
As a team effort, the council, supported by a ballot of all the council's tenants, overwhelmingly decided that the only way to deliver the new social housing (what we used to know as Council Housing) that the borough desperately needed was to set up an independent Local Housing Company. The result was West Devon Homes, which has offices at the Wharf in Tavistock and another in Okehampton.

The first chairman of WDH was a Lib Dem councillor and it is true that he made a superb job of it. I also serve on the board of trustees and am happy to give credit to all those involved. It has been a success story because of a team effort, not only of the councillors, but also of the staff of WDH and the independent and tenant trustees who now run WDH as a completely separate entity from the council.
As a result of those decisions and the subsequent work of the cross-party group of councillors who have just a third of the seats on WDH's Board of Trustees and even more of the work of the trustees elected by the tenants and those appointed from outside industry and other agencies, WDH has been a great success. West Devon now has, for the first time since I became a councillor, more social housing at the end of the year than it had at the beginning.

It was a team effort. I've said it before and I make no apology for saying again that one of the reasons why I stay independent is that I don't believe that party groups should claim exclusive credit for the successes of a council. Even politically-controlled councils have members not of the controlling party. Those make contributions, too. Controlled councils make it easier for the controlling party to claim credit. I don't agree with that.

If I were a Conservative councillor, I should have to go along with a similar approach to claiming credit for my party for all the good things that the council had achieved as a team. I don't want to do that. So I stay independent and free to "tell it like it is".

It's your decision on 1st May.

Published as an Internet document by R W Mathew, Willowby, Down Road, Tavistock, Devon